Golden Knights After 20 Games: Connelly Rises as Theodore’s Offense Slows
- Cargo
- NHL Games & Standings
- Shipped
- Shipper
- Ken Boehlke
- Readers
- 500
Trevor Connelly has earned a bigger role, while steadier goaltending and Shea Theodore’s defense lift Vegas. The fourth line and Theodore’s scoring remain concerns.


Twenty games have changed the questions surrounding the Golden Knights. Trevor Connelly has answered whether he belongs in the NHL; now the question is how much responsibility he can handle. Shea Theodore has shown he can shoulder a heavier defensive assignment, even as his offense has fallen well below his usual pace. And after a season in which goaltending consistency was a serious concern, Carter Hart and Adin Hill have given Vegas a steadier foundation.
That’s the strongest takeaway from this early assessment: several players have earned more trust, but the team still has a fourth line that hasn’t delivered the impact its construction suggested. Theodore’s split performance makes that contrast especially clear. His defensive stock is rising, while his scoring has slipped.
Connelly keeps earning a bigger role
Connelly began the season on the third line with Tomas Hertl and Victor Olofsson, and he quickly became a driving force for a unit that produced. Since then, the rookie has moved into both the first and second line mix, earned a place on the top power play unit and taken on more defensive work.
That progression says more than a strong start in sheltered minutes would. The Knights have expanded his assignments as the schedule has unfolded, giving him opportunities in higher profile roles and asking him to contribute away from the puck. Through 20 games, he has made the case that he can play at this level. The next test is sustaining that influence as his responsibilities grow.
Connelly is already being discussed as a Calder Trophy candidate, a striking position for a player whose initial task was simply to show he was ready for NHL action. His movement through the lineup gives Vegas options, too. He can help balance a scoring line or bring skill to a unit that needs a spark. The key question is no longer whether he can stay in the lineup; it’s how high he can climb in the forward group.
Hart and Hill provide steadier nights
Last season, Hart and Hill had good performances, but couldn’t deliver the consistent results Vegas needed, particularly early in games. That instability made it harder for the team to settle into its structure. The first 20 games have brought a meaningful change: both goalies have generally been good to excellent, with only a few outings they would want back.
The pair hasn’t become the NHL’s top goaltending tandem, and the improvement doesn’t erase every concern. Still, there’s less anxiety about which goalie gets the next start, and the defensive results have improved as the season has progressed. Reliable stops can give a team time to find its rhythm; steadier work from both goalies has given the Knights more of that room.
Theodore takes on the hard minutes
Theodore’s defensive work deserves a separate place among Vegas’ gains. He and Brayden McNabb regularly face the opposition’s best players, often beginning shifts in their own end. McNabb has long been trusted with those assignments. Theodore’s ability to handle them consistently was the question, and his play through 20 games has supplied a strong answer.
Theodore has been on the ice for 11 more Vegas goals than he has allowed, and the advanced numbers cited in the assessment support the view that his defensive results aren’t merely a short-lived run. He has taken on more of the workload since Alex Pietrangelo’s retirement, and the change has asked him to contribute in difficult situations night after night. He’s no longer defined only by his offensive skill; he’s become one of the roster’s most dependable defenders.
That progress has come with an offensive cost, at least so far. After averaging at least 0.6 points per game for six seasons before last year, Theodore recorded 10 goals and 39 points in 70 games last season, or 0.56 points per game. Through 20 games this year, he has seven points, with fewer of the standout offensive moments that have been part of his game in the past.
Losing his spot on the top power play unit was always likely to affect his production. Even so, Theodore had remained effective at five-on-five, which makes the early scoring drop notable. Twenty games is a limited sample, and one strong performance could help change the conversation. But the current blue-line setup and his expanded defensive role leave open the possibility that the 50-point seasons fans have come to expect may be harder to reach.
The fourth line needs more impact
Marc Gatcomb and Nic Dowd have yet to turn their fourth-line opportunity into the kind of influence Vegas expected. The Knights paid a substantial price in the trade for Dowd and the contract they took on, then brought in Gatcomb to replace Keegan Kolesar. Neither player has been a disaster. The issue is that the group looks capable of shaping games on paper, yet hasn’t consistently done so on the ice.
Gatcomb’s physicality hasn’t stood out as much as anticipated, while Dowd hasn’t fully met the defensive demands placed on him. Both are minus-six at five-on-five. The plan to use them for Ryan Craig’s “reset shifts” hasn’t taken hold either, limiting one of the intended ways the line could influence momentum.
There’s time for the pair to change that picture, and the early record doesn’t call for writing either player off. But the fourth line will need to show more of the defensive reliability and physical presence Vegas brought it in to provide. At the 20-game mark, Connelly’s rapid rise and Theodore’s dependable defense are clear gains; the next stretch will show whether the fourth line can join them.