Panthers Earn Point in Dallas but Can’t Finish After Tkachuk’s Early Goal
- Cargo
- NHL Games & Standings
- Shipped
- Shipper
- Ryan Gagne
- Readers
- 590
Matthew Tkachuk scored on the power play, but Casey DeSmith shut Florida out the rest of the way before Jason Robertson won it in overtime.


Florida had enough bite to make Dallas work for every inch, but one goal wasn’t enough to close the game. The Panthers took a 1-0 lead through Matthew Tkachuk, then watched the Stars pull even and win 2-1 in overtime Sunday at American Airlines Center. Jason Robertson ended it with a move in tight, leaving Florida with a point and a split of its two-game road trip.
The overtime loss puts the Panthers at 12-7-3 and keeps them in the Eastern Conference’s second wild-card position. The result also underlines the narrow margin Florida faced: after Tkachuk’s first-period power-play goal, neither team could solve the opposing goaltender until Robertson’s finish. Dallas got the extra point; Florida’s chance to take both slipped away in a game that stayed level for much of the night.
Tkachuk provides the early opening
Tkachuk’s goal mattered in part because scoring had been scarce for him. He entered the game with three goals, despite leading Florida with 29 points. His power-play strike against Dallas gave the Panthers the opening they needed and put his name on the scoresheet in a season when his production had leaned more toward setting up teammates than finishing chances.
The Tkachuk brothers have been frequent contributors for Florida. Matthew led the team in points, while Brady had 11 goals; across the Panthers’ first 21 games, the brothers had both been kept off the scoresheet only three times. Matthew’s finish in Dallas added another direct contribution to that run and showed the scoring threat he brings when he gets a shooting chance.
Still, an early lead didn’t turn into sustained separation. Dallas tied the game in the second period through Wyatt Johnston, and the 1-1 score held through the rest of regulation. Florida’s first goal created a useful cushion in the game’s flow, but the Panthers couldn’t add the next one that might have forced the Stars to chase.
DeSmith makes the lead stand up
Casey DeSmith was the main obstacle after Tkachuk scored. Dallas started him after Jake Oettinger had shut out Buffalo the previous night, a regular role for DeSmith in the second game of a back-to-back. His results in those situations had been strong: a 14-5-1 record and a .938 save percentage, as reported by the Stars.
Florida had just come off an emotional win over St. Louis, where it had generated early goals against Joel Hofer. That kind of fast start didn’t produce the same payoff in Dallas. The Panthers found the net once, then DeSmith kept them there while the Stars settled into the game and answered. The distinction is meaningful: Florida could create pressure, but it didn’t convert enough of its chances to make that pressure decisive.
Dallas also showed the defensive structure that makes it difficult to play from behind against the Stars. Once Johnston tied it, the teams traded attacks without another regulation goal. Akira Schmid kept Florida in the contest, and DeSmith matched him at the other end. Robertson’s overtime winner finally broke the deadlock, but the goaltending duel had already shaped the result by carrying the game beyond 60 minutes.
Physical edge without a penalty parade
The game grew chippy as the 1-1 tie persisted. Scrums followed whistles in the third period, and Florida brought back the edge that had been less visible in its wins over Detroit and St. Louis. Yet the Panthers took only two minor penalties, despite leading the NHL in penalty minutes, according to the linked team statistics.
That restraint mattered against a Dallas club with a dangerous power play. Florida played physically and held its ground after whistles without giving the Stars repeated chances with a man advantage. The Panthers have often been associated with an aggressive style, but this game showed that physical pressure can remain useful when it stays controlled. It helped keep the contest close even as the offense stalled.
Edmonton is next
Florida returns home Tuesday to face Edmonton, led by Connor McDavid, who had 53 points and led the NHL at the time of the game. It will be another demanding matchup for a Panthers team still trying to turn close contests into full wins. Aleksander Barkov and Brad Marchand were also expected to move closer to returning to the lineup, though no further timing was provided.
The Dallas game leaves Florida with a point and a clear next challenge: keep the physical pace, but find another finish after taking an early lead. Against Edmonton, the Panthers will need more than a strong opening shift if they want to make the result last.